What is Cookie Butter Coffee? A Biscoff Latte Guide

Discover Decadent Cookie Butter Coffee, Biscoff Lattes, & Spiced Holiday Flavors 

Ever heard of a cookie butter latte? This drink has gained popularity thanks to the rise of Biscoff cookie butter and its frequent appearance in cafes, seasonal menus, and social media recipes. While cookie butter coffee is often associated with winter and holiday flavors, it can be enjoyed year-round, especially by fans of flavored coffee sold online who enjoy experimenting with dessert-inspired brews at home...

Here, we will discuss what cookie butter tastes like, "what is cookie butter coffee," and more! We'll also add some links for cookie and spice coffee flavors, and a recipe to help you make your own dupe cookie butter coffee at home. Let's jump in!

What Is Cookie Butter Coffee?

Cookie butter coffee, also sometimes called a cookie butter latte, is a rich, indulgent coffee drink that blends brewed coffee or espresso with the warm, spiced sweetness of cookie butter.

The flavor profile is inspired by crushed spiced cookies, often Biscoff cookies, blended into a creamy spread that tastes like caramelized sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, and toasted butter. 

When added to coffee, cookie butter melts into the hot liquid, creating a velvety texture and a dessert-like experience that feels comforting and decadent without being overly complicated. With its warm, spiced notes, this drink is especially popular around the Holidays. Yum!

Looking for those delicious spiced cookie notes any time of year? Try these fragrant, boldly spiced, cookie-flavored black coffees:

• Flavored Christmas Cookies Coffee Grounds
• Flavored Cookiedoodle Coffee Grounds

Fresh roasted, ships quickly, available in flavored grounds or whole bean!

Why is cookie butter coffee popular? 

At its core, cookie butter coffee is about transforming a simple cup of coffee into something that tastes like a cozy bakery treat. It combines the bitterness of coffee with the sweetness and spice of cookie butter flavor, resulting in a balanced drink that feels indulgent yet approachable. Many people compare the taste to a spiced latte, gingerbread coffee, or even a cinnamon cookie soaked in espresso.

What does a cookie butter latte taste like?

In the simplest terms, cookie butter coffee is coffee flavored with cookie butter or cookie butter-inspired syrups and creamers. In more elevated versions, it becomes a latte topped with foam, spices, or whipped cream. Whether made with brewed coffee, espresso, or even a Keurig, cookie butter coffee delivers warmth, sweetness, and nostalgia in every sip.

What Is Cookie Butter?

Cookie butter is a spread made from crushed cookies blended with oils and sweeteners until smooth and creamy. It has a texture similar to peanut butter but a flavor closer to spiced shortbread or caramel cookies. The most famous version is Biscoff cookie butter, made from Lotus Biscoff cookies, which are thin, crunchy European biscuits flavored with cinnamon and brown sugar.

The idea behind cookie butter originated in Europe, where people enjoyed spreading crushed cookies on bread as a sweet alternative to jam. Over time, the concept evolved into a smooth, spoonable spread that could be used in desserts, baking, or simply eaten straight from the jar.

Cookie butter flavor is often described as warm, caramelized, spiced, and slightly toasted. It contains notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, vanilla, and brown sugar. This flavor profile makes it especially appealing when paired with coffee, as it complements coffee’s natural bitterness while enhancing its depth.

Pictured: A dessert dip with Biscoff cookie butter, Nutella, nuts, cookies, and spices

What is the difference between Biscoff and cookie butter?

Biscoff is the original brand of the spiced Belgian cookie, while "cookie butter" is the general term for the spreadable product made from puréed Biscoff (or similar speculoos) cookies; Biscoff spread (Lotus Biscoff) is often creamier, sweeter, and has a distinct molasses/caramel spice, while store-brand cookie butters (like Trader Joe's) can be heavier on the spice blend, slightly less sweet, or may have a different texture, but generally, they're all variations of the same delicious, cinnamon-spiced spread.

Is Cookie Butter Good in Coffee?

Yes, cookie butter is exceptionally good in coffee, especially for people who enjoy sweet, spiced drinks like gingerbread lattes, cinnamon vanilla coffee, or toffee-flavored brews. When stirred into hot coffee, cookie butter melts and emulsifies with the liquid, creating a creamy mouthfeel and rich aroma.

Cookie butter coffee works well because the spices in the cookies mirror many traditional coffee spices. Cinnamon, nutmeg, and caramelized sugar naturally enhance coffee rather than overpower it. This makes cookie butter coffee feel balanced rather than cloying.

It pairs especially well with medium and dark roast coffees, as well as dessert-inspired coffee flavors. Many people find that using the best flavored coffee as a base, such as gingerbread, Highlander Grogg, or double cinnamon vanilla, elevates the drink even further.

What Is the Difference Between Biscoff and Cookie Butter?

Biscoff is a brand name, while cookie butter is the general category. Biscoff cookies are a specific type of spiced Belgian biscuit, and Biscoff cookie butter is made exclusively from those cookies.

Cookie butter, on the other hand, can be made from many types of cookies. Some versions use graham crackers, ginger snaps, vanilla wafers, or shortbread. The flavor will vary depending on the cookies used, but Biscoff cookie butter remains the most recognizable and popular due to its distinct spice blend.

In coffee terms, Biscoff coffee usually refers to coffee flavored or topped with Biscoff cookie butter or syrup. Cookie butter coffee is a broader term that encompasses any coffee drink inspired by the flavor of cookie butter, whether homemade or café-style.

Pictured: Biscoff-style cookies 

Can You Make Cookie Butter at Home?

Yes, you can make cookie butter at home with just a few ingredients. Homemade cookie butter typically includes crushed cookies, a neutral oil such as coconut or avocado oil, a sweetener like sugar or maple syrup, and a small amount of milk or cream to adjust texture.

To make it, cookies are processed until fine, then blended with oil and sweetener until smooth. Spices like cinnamon and vanilla can be added to enhance the flavor. Homemade cookie butter allows you to control sweetness and spice, making it ideal for customizing cookie butter coffee recipes.

Where to Buy Cookie Butter?

Cookie butter is widely available at grocery stores, specialty food shops, and online retailers. Popular brands include Lotus Biscoff, Trader Joe’s cookie butter, and various organic alternatives.

For coffee lovers, pairing store-bought cookie butter with flavored coffee sold online is an easy way to recreate café-style drinks at home without needing specialty syrups.

How to Make Cookie Butter Coffee?

Making cookie butter coffee is simple. Start with hot-brewed coffee or espresso. Add one to two teaspoons of cookie butter and stir well until fully melted. Add milk, cream, or a dairy-free alternative to taste. Sweeten if needed, though cookie butter is often sweet enough on its own.

For an enhanced flavor experience, use a flavored coffee base such as gingerbread, Highlander Grogg, or toffee flavored coffee. These flavors naturally complement cookie butter and create a layered, bakery-style drink.

Pictured: Homemade cookie butter and spices

Cookie Butter Latte Recipe Using a Keurig

This easy recipe uses a Keurig and flavored coffee for convenience without sacrificing flavor.

Ingredients:

• One   re-usable K-cup  of Christmas cookie-flavored coffee from OneGreatCoffee.com
• One to two teaspoons of Biscoff cookie butter
• Half a cup of milk or milk alternative
• Optional whipped cream and cinnamon

Instructions:

• Brew the coffee pod using the Keurig on the strong setting if available.
• Heat the milk separately until warm and frothy.
• Add cookie butter to the hot coffee and stir until fully dissolved.
• Pour in warm milk and stir gently.
• Top with whipped cream and a light sprinkle of cinnamon if desired.

For a truly festive version, use Christmas cookie-flavored coffee from OneGreatCoffee.com, which pairs beautifully with Biscoff cookie butter and enhances the overall cookie butter flavor. You can explore their holiday flavors here:

 

Best Coffee Flavors to Pair With Cookie Butter

Cookie butter coffee shines when paired with complementary flavors. Some of the best flavored coffee options include gingerbread, Highlander Grogg, Christmas Highlander Grogg, toffee, and double cinnamon vanilla.

Highlander Grogg offers butterscotch and vanilla notes that enhance cookie butter richness. Gingerbread brings out the spice elements found in Biscoff cookies. Toffee flavors add depth and sweetness, while double cinnamon vanilla amplifies warmth and aroma.

Get Fresh Roasted Bags of Highlander Grogg Coffee Here

OneGreatCoffee.com offers a wide selection of rich, buttery, "Highlander Grog flavored" coffee for sale online, making it easy to experiment with cookie butter coffee drinks at home using high-quality beans. Their flavored selections are ideal for creating café-inspired drinks without artificial-tasting syrups!

Interesting Cookie Butter Facts

• Cookie butter was originally popularized in Belgium and the Netherlands.
• Biscoff cookies are often served on airplanes and with coffee due to their complementary flavor.
• Cookie butter contains no actual butter, despite its name.
• It pairs well with coffee because its spice blend mirrors traditional coffee seasonings.
• Cookie butter flavor has inspired ice creams, lattes, cheesecakes, and even cocktails.

Pictured: cookie butter spread, hand made

Final Thoughts on Cookie Butter Coffee

Cookie butter coffee is a comforting, flavorful way to elevate your daily coffee! Whether you use Biscoff cookie butter, make your own spread, or pair it with the best flavored coffee, this drink offers warmth, nostalgia, and indulgence in every sip.

OneGreatCoffee is Here to Help You Brew Coffee Bliss All Year Round!

By combining cookie butter flavor with high-quality flavored coffee sold online from OneGreatCoffee.com, you can enjoy café-quality drinks at home while exploring seasonal favorites like gingerbread, Highlander Grogg, and Christmas cookie blends.

Cookie butter coffee is proof that sometimes the most comforting flavors come from simple, familiar ingredients blended in creative ways. Check out our massive selection of over 160 flavored coffees (in decaf and regular) now for unprecedented coffee inspiration!